Page 2 of 3
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Wed May 18, 2011 4:22 pm
by Jane
Sorry Shawn, I meant to reply to you in my last post, as well as Caluna and Helenlegs. Thanks for the information.
Take care.
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Wed May 18, 2011 4:59 pm
by A's Mommy
Jane, welcome to HOPE. I am a patient of Dr. Hibner's in Phoenix, AZ. I live in Pennsylvania, though.
I am so curious as to the UK terms of doctors:
1) What is a Dr. (such as Dr. Baranowski)
2) What is a Mr. (such as Mr. Wong)
3) What is a Professor (such as Professor Carlstedt)
I guess I just don't know the difference because over here in the US, every doctor is a Dr.
Also, an M.D. is equal to a D.O. over here, except D.O.'s have additional training in Osteopathic Manipulative Therapy.
Best,
A's Mommy
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Wed May 18, 2011 5:57 pm
by calluna
A doctor is usually a medical doctor, although people who hold doctorates in other subjects (a Ph.D in other words) are also addressed as Doctor. Someone can also be MD PhD, which means that they have a medical degree, and have also written a dissertation. A surgeon is of course also a medical doctor, but as a matter of courtesy is addressed as Mr instead of Dr. In the case of a woman who is a surgeon, she is always addressed as Miss Whatever, even if she is married.
A professor is someone who holds or has held a chair in a particular subject at a university, he may also of course be a doctor or indeed a surgeon, or not. Prof Carlstedt is so addressed because he has held an assistant professorship at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm. He is also an MD PhD, as well as being a surgeon. So he could choose to be addressed as Mr Carlstedt, Dr Carlstedt, or Professor Carlstedt.
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Wed May 18, 2011 10:33 pm
by helenlegs 11
Wow Calluna, Thanks for that, If he could sort me out I would call him ANYTHING he wanted me to.
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_e_smile.gif)
Helen
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 12:17 am
by Lernica
calluna wrote: In the case of a woman who is a surgeon, she is always addressed as Miss Whatever, even if she is married.
I find this hilarious! So quaint! So . . . English! Contrary to its purported intentions, I find this form of address to be
less rather than
more respectful of female surgeons.
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Thu May 19, 2011 9:33 am
by calluna
Lernica wrote:calluna wrote: In the case of a woman who is a surgeon, she is always addressed as Miss Whatever, even if she is married.
I find this hilarious! So quaint! So . . . English! Contrary to its purported intentions, I find this form of address to be
less rather than
more respectful of female surgeons.
Well, it is definitely English. Also Welsh, Scottish and Irish as well, though! The UK is not just England, you know.
(Edited because on re-reading what I said, I realised that it might have come across as a bit of a sense of humour failure, and I certainly didn't intend that!)
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Mon May 30, 2011 10:39 am
by manon13
Having offended many "doctors" during my life in the Uk because I always used this term rather than Mr and having been baffled by the use of the word "consultant" for "specialist", I really appreciated the explanation!
Anyway I just wanted to alert you that Dr Bautrant is thinking about opening up a consultation and possibly doing surgery in London.
I think it would be a great idea because it would create more attention to this topic and clearly would be much more convenient for those wanting to have surgery with him. He could come once a month as Filler does (not that I would recommend him).
I said I would check for him if there is any interest.
Anyone interested?
On my side I am currently followed by Bautrant.
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Mon May 30, 2011 12:19 pm
by Kath
Manon,
That is great news for us in the UK, to have more choice. Does anyone know if you can have an MRN in the UK to help find the area of entrapment and then help you decide which surgery to go for?
Where in London does Dr Filler do a clinic then?
Thanks Manon for doing so much research, you are making such a big difference.
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:57 pm
by Jane
Hi Manon, I read your post with interest cos I too am under Dr B. I can't say I have ever heard of Dr Filler, where does he practise? I had two decompressions done by Professor Carlstedt, he works alongside Dr B at the London Hospital of Neurology, I am surprised you have not been referred to him. I think the more experience and knowledge we have in London the better. We appear to be dragging our heels in England compared to the States.
Re: Six years down the line!
Posted: Sat Jun 11, 2011 4:01 pm
by Jane
Kath, I am not sure what an MRN is. I have had two MRI's but as we all know they do not show up nerves.
I have read about a machine in New York that can pick up entrapments of the PN by 3 Tesla imaging and the doctor who reads the results is Dr Hollis POtter. To my knowledge there is no such machine in England unfortunately cos it would seem to be a major breakthrough for PNe sufferers.